Which job is safer from AI: Security Guards or First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers?

First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers is safer from AI based on ReplacedByAI risk scores. Security Guards has an AI replacement risk score of 63/100 (High), while First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers has a score of 25/100 (Low).

What is Security Guards's AI replacement risk?

Security Guards has an AI replacement risk score of 63/100, which ReplacedByAI classifies as high risk. Moderate risk: AI can reshape important parts of the role.

What is First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers's AI replacement risk?

First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers has an AI replacement risk score of 25/100, which ReplacedByAI classifies as low risk. Lower risk: the role depends more on human judgment and context.

Home/Compare/Security Guards vs First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers

AI Risk Comparison

Security Guards vs First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers

Compare AI replacement risk, automatable work, resilient skills, and potential career pivots for both occupations.

Safer role

First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers

Higher risk

Security Guards

Risk gap

38 points

Protective ServicesO*NET: 33-9032.00

Security Guards

Guard, patrol, or monitor premises to prevent theft, violence, or infractions of rules. May operate x-ray and metal detector equipment.

AI Risk Score

63/100

High

Moderate risk: AI can reshape important parts of the role.

Automation factors

Monitor and authorize entrance and departure of employees, visitors, and other persons to guard against theft and maintain security of premises.
Write reports of daily activities and irregularities, such as equipment or property damage, theft, presence of unauthorized persons, or unusual occurrences.
Answer telephone calls to take messages, answer questions, and provide information during non-business hours or when switchboard is closed.
Documenting/Recording Information
Evaluating Information to Determine Compliance with Standards

Top skills

Active Listening3.75/5

Monitoring3.38/5

Speaking3.25/5

Critical Thinking3.12/5

Coordination3.12/5

Recommended career pivots

First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers25/100 Transit and Railroad Police83/100 Transportation Security Screeners81/100 Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers82/100 Parking Enforcement Workers67/100

Protective ServicesO*NET: 33-1091.00

First-Line Supervisors of Security Workers

Directly supervise and coordinate activities of security workers and security guards.

AI Risk Score

25/100

Low

Lower risk: the role depends more on human judgment and context.

Automation factors

Monitor and authorize entry of employees, visitors, or other persons.
Write reports documenting observations made while on patrol.
Monitor the behavior of security employees to ensure adherence to quality standards, deadlines, or procedures.
Working with Computers
Evaluating Information to Determine Compliance with Standards

Top skills

Active Listening4.00/5

Reading Comprehension3.88/5

Speaking3.88/5

Critical Thinking3.88/5

Judgment and Decision Making3.88/5

Recommended career pivots

Security Managers26/100 First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers30/100 First-Line Supervisors of Passenger Attendants4/100 Security Management Specialists39/100 First-Line Supervisors of Housekeeping and Janitorial Workers26/100

Take the quiz to see your personal AI risk score

A job title only tells part of the story. Answer a few questions about your actual work and get a personalized AI risk assessment.

Take the AI Risk Quiz